GitHub Copilot vs Claude
Side-by-side comparison of the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy of GitHub Copilot and Claude.
GitHub offers meaningful privacy controls, deletion and portability rights, private-repo confidentiality promises, and advance notice for material changes. But the service also takes broad rights to use content for service improvement and AI training, collects extensive data, limits liability heavily, and allows sharing with affiliates and advertising partners in some contexts.
GitHub Copilot is governed by GitHub’s general terms and privacy rules. The documents are relatively transparent and include user rights like access, deletion, portability, cookie controls, and notice before material policy changes. Key tradeoffs are broad licenses over content and AI inputs/outputs, AI training by default unless you opt out, strong warranty/liability disclaimers, and broad data collection and sharing for product improvement and some advertising contexts.
Points of interest
-
negative ●●●●● termsStrong liability disclaimer
The service is provided as-is, with broad warranty disclaimers and major limits on GitHub’s liability for losses, downtime, or data issues. If Copilot or GitHub causes harm, your remedies may be very limited.
-
negative ●●●●○ termsAI training by default
Copilot inputs and outputs can be used to develop and improve GitHub and affiliate AI models unless you opt out. This matters if you do not want prompts, code context, or generated outputs used for model improvement.
-
negative ●●●●○ termsBroad content license
Even though you keep ownership, GitHub gets broad rights to host, copy, analyze, display, and use your content to run and improve the service, including AI-related improvement. For public content, other users can also view and fork it under platform rules.
-
positive ●●●●○ termsPrivate repos treated confidentially
GitHub expressly says private repository contents are confidential and limits staff access to listed situations like security, support, service integrity, or legal compliance. This is a meaningful protection for non-public code.
-
positive ●●●●○ privacyAccess, deletion, portability rights
GitHub says eligible users can access, correct, delete, restrict, object to processing, withdraw consent, and receive portable copies of their data. These are strong, user-helpful privacy rights.
-
negative ●●●○○ termsOutputs may infringe or fail
GitHub warns Copilot output may be inaccurate, incomplete, vulnerable, or resemble third-party code, and puts review responsibility on you. Users cannot rely on output being safe or license-clean.
-
negative ●●●○○ privacyExtensive data collection
GitHub collects account data, content, device and usage data, cookies, support data, geolocation, and information from third parties. That gives the company a broad picture of your activity across the service.
-
negative ●●●○○ privacyAffiliate and ad sharing
Data may be shared with affiliates including Microsoft, service providers, partners, authorities, and in some cases advertising and analytics networks. The policy also says some personal information is "shared" for marketing and audience measurement under applicable law.
-
positive ●●●○○ termsAI opt-out available
You can opt out of having Copilot inputs and outputs used for AI model development going forward. This is a practical privacy control, though it does not undo broader repository-content licenses elsewhere in the terms.
-
positive ●●●○○ termsClear cancellation and deletion
Account cancellation is described as a simple self-serve flow, and GitHub says it will generally delete your full profile and repository contents within 90 days, subject to backups and legal exceptions. You can also request a copy of account contents within 90 days.
-
positive ●●●○○ privacyCookie controls honored
GitHub offers multiple ways to reject non-essential cookies, including settings links, browser controls, Do Not Track, extensions, and Global Privacy Control. It also states it does not sell data and will not share data when GPC is detected.
-
positive ●●○○○ terms30-day change notice
GitHub promises advance notice for material changes to both the terms and privacy statement. That gives users some time to review updates before they take effect.
Documents
The service includes several user-friendly protections—no mandatory arbitration, local court access for EEA/Swiss users, user rights in inputs/outputs, clear deletion timing, portability, and a statement that it does not sell personal data. But it also defaults to using prompts and outputs for model training, collects broad technical and content data, auto-renews subscriptions, limits liability, and allows suspension/termination with potential deletion of account materials.
Claude’s consumer terms for EEA/Swiss users are relatively transparent and preserve user ownership of inputs while assigning output rights to users. Privacy terms are mixed: Anthropic collects substantial usage and content data and may use prompts/outputs for model training by default unless you opt out, but it offers deletion, access, portability, objection rights, and says it does not sell personal data. Disputes stay in court rather than mandatory arbitration.
Points of interest
-
negative ●●●●○ termsTraining on chats by default
Your prompts, outputs, and feedback may be used to improve services and train models unless you opt out. Even after opting out, flagged content and reported feedback can still be used for training or safety review.
-
positive ●●●●○ termsNo mandatory arbitration
Users can bring disputes in court, and EEA/Swiss consumers may also file claims in their local courts. That preserves ordinary legal remedies instead of forcing private arbitration.
-
positive ●●●●○ termsYou keep input rights
Anthropic says you retain rights in your submitted content, and it assigns any rights it has in outputs to you. This is unusually favorable compared with services that claim broad ownership over user content.
-
positive ●●●●○ privacyClear deletion timeline
Deleted conversations are removed from your history immediately and from Anthropic’s back-end within 30 days. This is a concrete and user-friendly retention promise for chat history.
-
positive ●●●●○ privacyNo sale of personal data
Anthropic expressly says it does not “sell” personal data under applicable privacy laws. It also offers opt-outs for targeted advertising and says it honors global privacy controls.
-
negative ●●●○○ privacyBroad data collection
Anthropic collects not just account and payment details, but also prompts, outputs, support messages, IP address, device data, usage logs, and cookies. That gives the service a detailed picture of your activity and interactions.
-
negative ●●●○○ termsAuto-renewing subscription
Paid plans renew automatically unless canceled at least 24 hours before the end of the current term. Payments are generally nonrefundable outside legal cancellation rights.
-
negative ●●●○○ termsCan change terms and service
Anthropic may revise the terms and modify, suspend, or discontinue services, usually with 30 days' notice for material changes. This gives it significant flexibility to alter features, pricing, or rules later.
-
negative ●●●○○ termsLiability cap applies
If something goes wrong, Anthropic’s liability is capped at the greater of what you paid in the prior six months or €100, subject to mandatory legal exceptions. That can sharply limit compensation for losses.
-
positive ●●●○○ privacyAccess and portability rights
Depending on location, users may request access, deletion, correction, portability, restriction, objection, and consent withdrawal. The policy also points to Privacy Settings and a dedicated privacy email for requests.
-
negative ●●○○○ termsTermination may delete data
Anthropic may suspend or terminate access for breaches, legal compliance, security needs, or long inactivity, and it may delete materials tied to your account after termination. Users should not assume indefinite access to stored chats or content.
-
neutral ●●○○○ privacyInternational data transfers
Personal data may be transferred to the US and other countries, with Anthropic relying on adequacy decisions or standard contractual clauses. This is common, but it means your data may be processed outside your home jurisdiction.
Documents
Comparison is based on each service's published Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Read the source documents linked above before relying on any specific clause.